Wishlist Member vs. MemberPress
Wishlist Member has been a top WordPress membership plugin for quite some time. The problem comparing many WordPress membership plugins is they are all similar in a lot of ways. This is what makes MemberPress interesting. It is unlike nearly every other plugin on the market. The big question is whether or not this is a good thing or not.
1. Ease of Use
Like most popular membership site management plugins Wishlist Member utilizes a layout and interface as the WordPress dashboard. While no one would ever confuse it for the WordPress Dashboard the transition between one and other is fairly seamless. Much of the setup and customization is reliant on the point-and-click strategy. This is the area in which MemberPress easily stands out. The entire setup process is rules-based. This means for every piece of protected content a set of rules must be created. While this is a great idea in theory because it offers unlimited customization the reality is much different. This is because rules must be created and applied to every piece of content and membership level. As a result, the initial setup process can quickly start to feel tedious. Plus a rules-based mistake in regards to membership levels can undermine the rules setup for individual products and pieces of content.
2. Potential for Problems
In the short term there is no doubt the potential for technical problems within Wishlist Member is minimal. It is one of the most mature plugins in the marketplace so any major problem has been dealt with long ago. On the other hand, many users have reported errors with MemberPress. It is difficult to tell if many of these are legitimate errors or just mistakes caused by setting up rules incorrectly, but either way there are a lot of concerns out there. The point of buying a WordPress membership plugin is to save time and eliminate the need to worry about protecting content. In this case, MemberPress leaves some people wanting more.
3. 3rd Party Integration
Another problem caused by heavy use of rules within MemberPress is it doesn’t always get along with 3rd party plugins very well. This is particularly problematic for WordPress users because plugins are critical to getting the most out of the flexibility the WordPress platform has to offer. On the other hand, Wishlist Member has a range of 3rd party plugins built specifically to work with Wishlist Member. Plus, since very little changes within the core framework of the Wishlist Member plugin there is little chance of large-scale compatibility issues in the future. MemberPress is still too young to predict whether any major compatibility issues will arise.
4. Refund Policy
While it may not seem like a big deal the lack of refund policy offered by MemberPress is concerning. It is understanding to have a tight refund policy in regards to digital products, especially applications, but have no refund policy out all is problematic. If someone has tried MemberPress and legitimately doesn’t want to every use it again they still won’t be able to get their money back. It also speaks to faith, or lack thereof, on behalf of the developers behind MemberPress.
If these are the only two options you are considering then Wishlist Member is the clear winner. Not only is it one of the strongest and most reliable options on the market but it is also has a strong track record of keeping customers happy and satisfied with their purchase.
Single License: $97
3-Site License: $194
Unlimited License: $297
Single License: $99